(OK, so I lied. One more thing before I go silent for a little while …)
Perry (”Acolyte”) from Energetic Procession has posted an excerpt from the acts of the Fifth Ecumenical Council, which he presents as a piece of counter-evidence to Catholic claims about the Papacy. Perry notes that he has not been able to find a Catholic treatment of this particular quote in the Catholic apologetical literature since the nineteenth century. From a cursory glance at the literature in my possession, I can confirm that while detailed pro-papal treatments on the Fifth Council do exist*, but I haven’t found a lengthy discussion of this particular excerpt. I invite my readers to post comments over at Energetic Procession. Hopefully, time permitting, I will post my own reflections on this excerpt in the near future.
I certainly welcome this overt recognition of a rather authoritative counter to papal claims.
I wonder how it is that a conciliar statement, from one of the universally recognized seven ecumenical councils, does not settle the question for you. Why seek the debate back and forth over secondary sources and their respective arguments, when the original source is so clear?
I’m closing the comments on this post. Please leave your comments over at Energetic Procession. I hope to post my reaction to the quote soon.